Stop the Scroll: How to Craft Blog Titles People Actually Click

“Don’t judge a book by its cover” might go back to the 1800s, but let’s be honest, everyone still does. Especially online.

Today, your blog is the book, and the search engine results page (SERP) is the cover. It’s a level playing field. However, the one thing that makes people click–or scroll right past–is your (drumroll, please)… blog title.

Why Blog Titles Still Rule in 2025

No matter how good your blog is, people won’t read it if they don’t click it. That’s where your title comes in.

Here’s what a great title needs to do:

• Grab attention instantly
• Help your blog show up on search engines (yes, still important)
• Spark curiosity or solve a problem your reader cares about

A bad blog title is like sending a killer gift with zero wrapping paper. Nobody notices it. 

5 Ingredients for a Blog Title That Works

1. Say What Your Readers Want to Hear

Your blog title should meet your audience right where they are, whether they’re confused, curious, or in research mode.

• Instead of: “Blog Title Best Practices”
• Try: “5 Blog Title Tweaks That Will Boost Clicks Overnight”

This way, you’re promising a solution in plain language. Bonus points if you sound like you get what they’re dealing with!

2. Be a Tease–Not a Spoiler!

You don’t have to give away the whole blog in your title. You just need to give enough. 

• Too much: “How to Write a Blog Title Using Keywords, Storytelling, Numbers, and Emotional Hooks”
• Just right: “How to Write a Blog Title That Actually Gets Clicks”

Let the content do the heavy lifting. Your title is just the invitation!

3. Match the Intent (Not Just the Keyword)

Most people don’t type “blog title strategies 2025” into the search engine. Instead, they ask, “how do I write a blog title that works?”

Your title should reflect how people search, not just what they search for.

For example, a marketer might search:

• “How to write blog titles that convert”
• “Best blog title format for SEO 2025”
• “Catchy marketing blog title examples”

So, use those phrases naturally. A blog title like “How to Write Blog Titles That Actually Drive Traffic” works because it speaks directly to what people are asking.

4. Use Numbers (But Only When They Make Sense!)

People love numbers–when they’re relevant. Don’t force them, but do use them when they organize your content.

For example, compare:

• “Blog Tips That Help with Clicks”
• “7 Blog Title Fixes That’ll Instantly Boost Your CTR”

The second option is clear, structured, and clickable. 

However, don’t overdo it. Numbers work when they promise value, not when they’re used for show. 

5. Get your Keywords in There (But Keep It Smooth)

Yes, SEO still matters. According to Backlinko, title tags between 40-60 characters have the highest CTR. This means your blog title should be short enough to show up fully in search, and smart enough to include your main keyword.

If possible, place your keyword at the beginning of the title:

• Good: “Digital Marketing Trends in 2025: What to Expect”
• Not ideal: “What to Expect in the World of Digital Marketing Trends in 2025”

Bonus Sprinkle: Curiosity, Emotion, and Clarity

In 2025, a great blog title needs to make people feel something. That could be curiosity, relief, urgency–even fear (the good kind).

For example, compare:

• “SEO Mistakes to Avoid”
• “5 Costly SEO Mistakes That Are Killing Your Traffic”

Which one makes you want to click?… Exactly!

Use words like: 

Effortless, proven, mistakes, secrets, surprising, smart, ultimate.

But don’t overhype it! Your blog needs to deliver what the title promises. 

Good Vibes Only (Your CTR Will Thank You)

According to Backlinko, titles with positive sentiment can boost click-through rates by up to 4.1%. That’s a decent lift, especially when every click counts.

Here’s how tone plays a role:

• Positive: “7 Simple Email Tricks That Make Customers Smile”
• Neutral: “7 Email Marketing Tips for Beginners”
• Negative: “7 Email Marketing Mistakes That Are Killing Your Engagement”

All 3 work in different contexts, but positivity often performs best when the goal is approachability and trust. 

That said, don’t force it! Choose the tone that fits your message and your reader’s mindset.

Talk to Your Reader Like You Know Them

Want to win clicks? Use second-person language. Make it feel personal.

For example, compare:

• “Marketing Tips for Startups”
• “7 Marketing Tips Every Small Business Needs to Hear in 2025”

The second one sounds like you’re talking to someone, not just broadcasting into the void.

Common Mistakes to Avoid (Because We’ve All Done Them)

1. Being Vague

“Digital Marketing in 2025”: Too broad. Tell us what you’re offering.

2. Ignoring SEO

No keywords? No visibility! It’s that simple.

3. Clickbaiting

As they say, “Don’t promise the moon and deliver a flashlight.”

Let’s Recap… Your Title Checklist for 2025

• Is it clear?
• Does it include your main keyword?
• Does it spark curiosity or solve a problem?
• Is it under 60 characters?
• Could it be a conversation starter with your ideal reader?

Ready to Write a Title That Stops the Scroll?

If you want people to read your blog, start with a headline that earns the click. Clarity, intent, and a dash of emotion will always beat cleverness for the sake of it. 

So, keep that trifecta in mind, add a pinch of SEO magic, and you’re ready to cook up your next blog title masterpiece.

For more marketing tips, subscribe to the PIXL newsletter and get them straight into your inbox!